Saunders, Real Estate, Hamptons

1199 Comments by ICE

<<  1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |  5  |  6  |  7  |  8  |  9  |  10  |  11  |  12  |  >>  

East Quogue woman files $70 million lawsuit against Suffolk County and Southampton Town

If the police did their job wouldn't the charge have stuck? It seems they failed by locking an innocent person up for 5 days on a bogus charge. I think they were right to check her out and verify her story, to ascertain whether or not she was in fact a "terrorist" which would be highly unlikely, being that she was stopped on the side of the road in broad daylight taking these pictures. A "terrorist would likely have their guns at the ready not stored in the trunk, following the proper procedure for transport. Besides the terrorists we need to worry about aren't likely going to be using guns to harm us, They like car bombs, IEDs and airplanes.
They should have checked her out verified her identity and right to have those weapons. The if the photos were an issue confiscate the memory card. Then release her as she posed no threat. " Jul 30, 10 7:35 PM

What makes someone a "whack job"? a. owning guns, b. not subscribing to a liberal ideology, c. not agreeing with you, d. all of the above" Jul 30, 10 7:39 PM

Who are you to determine what someone should or should not do with their time. Many people enjoy target shooting, if you don't that is fine. Anyone going to or coming from shooting range may be "carrying an assault rifle and shotgun as well as 500 rounds of ammo. Maybe more than just two weapons as the legal number you may transport is 19 so she was well within the law." Jul 30, 10 7:49 PM

Guess what, all of those shootings were done with pistols. Your logic doesn't hold, because she owns a guns she is going to use it in an illegal manner or to harm someone. The statistics just don't support you phobia. " Jul 30, 10 7:53 PM

They didn't "detain" her, they charged her with trespass, which didn't hold up in court. She was free to leave the jail upon posting $50,000. That isn't detainment, that is a wrongful arrest and malicious prosecution. The knew she wasn't a threat before she was removed the scene. If the photographs she took were so illegal why wasn't she charged with violating that law/policy? " Jul 30, 10 8:00 PM

Even if she were a loose cannon that wouldn't change her equal protection under the constitution. " Jul 30, 10 8:05 PM

How do you propose I speak those dead people? We will see who was right when this case goes to trial, I'm betting there will be a payout considering she was held on a bogus charge." Jul 30, 10 8:37 PM

P.S. If you have to try and discredit a valid point with a spelling correction it shows you have no valid supporting argument." Jul 30, 10 8:38 PM

Get a grip the Airmen were never in danger. " Jul 30, 10 8:46 PM

What law did she break? Why wasn't she charged with this law she broke? Obviously the trespassing didn't occur or it wouldn't have been dismissed.
Please give your opinion on guns, not that it will be supported by any law or facts. Just your ignorance on the matter.
You seem to be interested in laws being upheld. here is a comment you posted:

"Wow dont hold back gallery girl why dont you make youself a sign and go stand outside the 7 eleven in southampton in the mornings, with you buddy"

Sounds like you don't support our Federal immigration law, are certain laws optional when it comes to enforcement?
Many illegal immigrants break more than just the one law upon entering, they add forgery and identity theft to their resume. Is this okay by you?" Jul 30, 10 8:56 PM

All you who have questioned and attacked her right to own those guns have made it a 2nd amendment issue. An arrest that doesn't result in a conviction may result in compensation." Jul 30, 10 9:03 PM

As for the pictures of a military installation, go on google earth, there are pictures of Area 51 in NV the top secret base. Are we to believe WHAFB's heli is more of a concern?" Jul 30, 10 9:08 PM

Have you never heard the expression "broad daylight"?" Jul 30, 10 9:13 PM

How thick are you? Her being held in jail for 5 days had nothing to do with the Patriot Act and it's provisions for unconstitutional detainment of American citizens.
She was held in jail on a Trespass charge which was dismissed, which equals the court saw it as she didn't do it! " Jul 30, 10 9:19 PM

Not in this instance. " Jul 30, 10 9:21 PM

Fair enough, then why didn't the charge stick? How do you know so much about planning terrorist attacks?" Jul 30, 10 9:24 PM

Vice President Joe Biden vacations in Southampton

It's the weekend. What about Cheney's trips to Jackson Hole as VP you don't think he went by mule all by his lonesome do you?" Jul 30, 10 9:47 PM

Two boats collide on Peconic Bay near Robins Island

Yes, you said from, but interpreted it differently than in was meant in the context used.

I would imagine the "kooks" who have trust funds don't have to play the waiting game, they fly to were there are waves! Being a real surfer isn't determined by one economic status, it is in their love of the activity and their edict in the water.

Presumptuousness is usually ignorant, as was yours in assuming I assumed you knew nothing of surfing.;-) " Jul 30, 10 9:55 PM

it was meant. Too quick to hit the submit button!" Jul 30, 10 9:57 PM

East Quogue woman files $70 million lawsuit against Suffolk County and Southampton Town

Not implying anything just curious as to the source of your claimed knowledge of terrorist thought processes.
Once again I ask if it is illegal to take the photos, why didn't they charge her with that and if that is what the trespass charge was in relation too, why didn't it stick?" Jul 31, 10 5:19 PM

I doubt the evaluation took 5 days." Jul 31, 10 5:21 PM

You are defending stupidity, you are defending the the police who arrested her and charged her ineffectually. That seems to be a fairly stupid move as the lawsuit reflects. " Jul 31, 10 5:24 PM

A 5 day "psychiatric observation" seems doubtful? 36 or 48 hours sure." Jul 31, 10 5:30 PM

She was before the bench for a bogus charge, so any detainment was unjustified due to the fact she should have been before the bench. " Jul 31, 10 5:36 PM

"could border on sedition." This was about her cyberspace comments or was it? If it was then it seems as though her lawsuit may have some validity after all.
If they aren't deemed seditious then they are covered under the first amendment.
Once again she wasn't charged with anything relating to this. " Aug 1, 10 6:05 PM

"could border on sedition." This was about her cyberspace comments or was it? If it was then it seems as though her lawsuit may have some validity after all.
If they aren't deemed seditious then they are covered under the first amendment.
Once again she wasn't charged with anything relating to this. " Aug 1, 10 6:05 PM

Don't compare her to a fence jumping criminals who have no right to be here." Aug 1, 10 6:06 PM

Pants wetting is rational now?" Aug 1, 10 6:07 PM

It's a sad day in our Military's history when the civilian sector has to protect them." Aug 1, 10 6:09 PM

"She broke the law even though it seems like a small issue"

I was merely pointing out that ICARE seems to CARE about laws being broken in this case, but not in others.

Jul 31, 10 8:34 PM
"so you think they can just round up whoever they like whenever they like?
Sounds like Berlin in the 40's to me. Innocent until proven guilty, not the other way around. Just to clarify, it is their job to protect and serve, not illegally detain and trample constitutional rights. "

where do you stand on illegal immigration? Would you apply the same standard?
elliot (sag harbor)
Total comments by elliot

Pot calling the kettle much elliot? How can you be so foolish as to accuse me of do something which you yourself had just done a little over 3 hours prior? " Aug 1, 10 6:19 PM

Still dodging the question: Once again I ask if it is illegal to take the photos, why didn't they charge her with that and if that is what the trespass charge was in relation too, why didn't it stick?" Aug 1, 10 6:23 PM

Exactely! Hence the 70 million$ lawsuit! LOL
" Aug 1, 10 6:25 PM

Oh and ICARE, I see you didn't try to touch the "too easy" gun issue because they were legal and properly transported. " Aug 1, 10 6:30 PM

Well, I guess that's better than being a second rate whack job or a pants wetting gun hater." Aug 1, 10 6:33 PM

Two guns is an arsenal? You are so hysterical is is amazing. People like you are the reason the NRA exists.

"You are a potentially dangerous person." This is a benign statement as any human being operating a motor vehicle is "potentially dangerous". Ease up on your support for thought crime and worst case scenario paranoia. " Aug 1, 10 6:42 PM

Yeah in other parts of the world, so your point is what? Kim Jong il wouldn't stand for it, so why should we? This is America still, I think.
If it is as you say and she was detained for her rants, then the allegations in her lawsuit seem to have some factual support. You can't detain some one because you don't agree with their ideology if they haven't broken the law. Think about it, she was charged by the county for breaking a federal law, this makes no sense. " Aug 1, 10 6:49 PM

Why don't you move if you don't like this country?" Aug 1, 10 6:54 PM

Wildwood Lake closed over weekend

Shinnecock Bay has red tide as of two days ago! Baby Blue Claw Crabs are washing up dead all over. Let's see how long it takes 27e to break this story." Aug 1, 10 6:57 PM

East Quogue woman files $70 million lawsuit against Suffolk County and Southampton Town

You resort to a personal attack by calling me a fool? That is weak and shows how you can't stick to this issues. You need to reread your response because nowhere in it did you address the "too easy' gun.
Earlier you claimed I called you ignorant, but it is a lack of your understanding of the English language which caused you to misinterpret what I wrote. "Please give your opinion on guns, not that it will be supported by any law or facts. Just your ignorance on the matter." This is not saying you are ignorant across the board, just that on the issue of guns and their legal possession and transportation you are ignorant.
BTW, I don't watch any Court TV. I rarely watch TV in general." Aug 1, 10 8:22 PM

No, but last time I checked the constitution was still intact. It sure seems to be when we want loitering day labors off our streets. I remember getting harassed by Police for skateboarding as a kid, but now it is okay to loiter as an illegal immigrant who should even be in the country? Hmmmmm" Aug 1, 10 8:26 PM

Valid point, but don't forget in those countries you would not even have the right to say what you think as you are fortunate enough to do here, Be careful how quick you are to subjugate other's rights, for your rights could swiftly follow." Aug 1, 10 8:29 PM

Vice President Joe Biden vacations in Southampton

5 is too long, let the summer people be gone! September and October are so nice out here!" Aug 1, 10 8:31 PM

Nice to see someone not respond to the puppet strings!" Aug 1, 10 8:38 PM

East Quogue woman files $70 million lawsuit against Suffolk County and Southampton Town

Exactly, you called her a whack job = you losing the argument.
The second rate whack job was me being sarcastic about you comment and not directed at you personally. The pants wetting gun hater is you though.;-)" Aug 1, 10 8:43 PM

Talk about name calling.... LOL Pot calling the kettle shelliot!" Aug 1, 10 8:46 PM

Go back and read who wrote that, it wasn't me genius. lol I apply the law equally to all, I would deport an illegal Irish, Polish, Russian, Israeli, English or any other nationality just as quick as someone from Mexico, Central or South America. For you to try and use the race card on me shows how pathetic your position is. I don't want anyone or any race, nationality or religion here illegally.
I have friends of many different nationalities and races, but they all have one thing in common, the one who live here are LEGALLY here. Get it illegal isn't a race or nation, it's a status.

Once again I ask if it is illegal to take the photos, why didn't they charge her with that and if that is what the trespass charge was in relation too, why didn't it stick?" Aug 1, 10 8:56 PM

Her rants weren't why they stopped her though, it was for the picture taking, either way they were stupid to arrest her and charge her with something that wouldn't stick.
True many people have ranted much less and committed far worse acts of aggression, the quiet ones are the ones you need to really worry about! Think of how unassuming most serial killers are." Aug 1, 10 9:59 PM

The last part is crazy, everyone knows the FEMA coffins are in Georgia! LOL" Aug 1, 10 10:00 PM

Oh, you got me.... I guess I'll just wear my hood to the supermarket from now on. " Aug 1, 10 10:49 PM

Good redirect from your inability to answer the simple question:

If it is illegal to take the photos, why didn't they charge her with that and if that is what the trespass charge was in relation to, why didn't it stick?

I will agree she didn't use the best judgement in her approach to photographing the helicopter. I never said it was unreasonable for the police to detain her at the scene and ascertain wether or not she was a threat. Where they screwed up was arresting her and charging her with criminal trespassing.

Think the photography rule/law is a Federal one, why would the County charge her for breaking a law they don't have jurisdiction over?

I concede no defeat to one who can not answer simple questions." Aug 2, 10 12:42 AM

When transporting them in a car in this state the place for up to 19 of them is in the trunk. They were completely legit and shouldn't have been confiscated. Her son could have taken them home, but the police wanted to bust her chops. Now she is busting back.

As for guns killing people: Guns kill people like spoons made Rosie O'Donnell fat." Aug 2, 10 12:49 AM

Mr. Z - Fact: The guns were confiscated and held for 6 months after her charge was officially dismissed. That is is a violation of her 2nd amendment rights, there was no legal justification for the confiscation of the legally transported firearms.
Fact: Thought crime is not yet on the books, except in the case of hate crime legislation. Not agree with someone ideologies doesn't grant the right to infringe on a constitutional right.

The cash is a non issue, because it is not illegal to have $13,000 on your person unless you are flying on a commercial flight.

As for the bogus criminal trespassing charge which was the impetus for her incarceration. Intent to trespass would be difficult to prove as intent is generally one of the most difficult things to prove in a trial.
If taking photos is illegal as has been claimed by many, then they should have charged her with it. To hold a 30 year resident on $50,000 bail on a criminal trespass charge is a gross misuse of power by the Judge.
Bottom line is she was held in jail for a charge that was dismissed, that alone justifies compensation.
I'm not saying 70,000,000, but she will be paid for the mishandling of this incident.

" Aug 2, 10 4:28 PM

mystcstar - You're welcome. Please do your self a favor and don't take the bait! Let your debating on this take place in the court room through your lawyers. In a forum where fact and law rule you will prevail. In here emotion and opinion rule, so it isn't worth jeopardizing a solid case." Aug 2, 10 4:32 PM

Finally you admit she was held in jail on the criminal trespassing charge, which was dismissed. This equals false arrest and malicious prosecution. The excessive bail will be addressed in the suit as well, I would imagine." Aug 2, 10 4:35 PM

Any school that could get their hands on it!" Aug 2, 10 4:37 PM

That was weak removing my comment, it was a legitimate sarcastic question to the above sarcastic comment!" Aug 2, 10 4:41 PM

If it was truly a national security concern do you really think the SHPD would have been the arresting agency? If it was the case then the FBI would have taken her away not the Town Police.

" Aug 2, 10 4:46 PM

She was basically unarmed, consider how long it would take her to open her trunk, unlock her guns and ammo, then load them. The soldier at the gate has a loaded gun in a tactical holster on their thigh, as well as an automatic rifle probably a M4. " Aug 2, 10 4:52 PM

22 and fresh out of law school? Hmmmm graduate high school 17-18 + 4 years to a BA = 21-22 then 3 years law school = 24-25 minimum. Seems like you used some fuzzy math. Don't forget most of the lawyers working for the county couldn't get jobs in private firms." Aug 2, 10 5:03 PM

Nine rescued from sinking boat on Sunday

First thing I thought, nine people on a 19' boat?" Aug 2, 10 6:28 PM

Vice President Joe Biden vacations in Southampton

LOL, LOL, LOL... Urban Dictionary, the same place one would go for the definition of an "Angry Moose" LOL!!!!!!!" Aug 2, 10 7:22 PM

Good Idea! They could form a human bridge so the poor illegals wouldn't have to get wet on their river crossing." Aug 2, 10 7:23 PM

Stanley??? Wow, that is quite manly.

He could disprove all these "lunatic conspiracies" by simply producing his BIRTH CERTIFICATE. Why wouldn't he do this? Unless there is something to hide, such as an out of country birthplace." Aug 3, 10 12:33 AM

East Quogue woman files $70 million lawsuit against Suffolk County and Southampton Town

Why a plea bargin? It says charges dismissed, not dismissed in satisfaction. She was on a public road on the opposite side of the road from the base. What she was doing doesn't meet the description of the charge. She may have been taking photos, but that doesn't fit the charge. The Air National Guard officials do not have jusristiction over CR31. The above statement is therefore irrelevant do to her being out of their juristiction at the time of this incident." Aug 3, 10 12:47 AM

Explain how it looks like a plea bargain since you seem to "see" it." Aug 3, 10 12:48 AM

"She makes people"around" her lives miserable"

You are responsible for your own happiness, if you defer to outside sources for it you risk never being happy." Aug 3, 10 12:50 AM

Exactly, being charged without valid reason can lead to dismissal, which can lead to false arrest suits." Aug 3, 10 12:52 AM

No doubt, I don't know why I was thinking they would handle the suit in house." Aug 3, 10 5:08 PM

Vice President Joe Biden vacations in Southampton

Yeah, what a crazy idea to have to show your birth certificate to prove you are who you say you are and were born where you say you were, for the highest office in the country. We all have to do it for drivers licenses and passports, I guess it is completely unreasonable to expect Obummer to do the same." Aug 3, 10 5:14 PM

Is Blowes retiring? This week, the answer is: maybe

Who will take Mr. Blowes job?" Aug 3, 10 7:39 PM

Vice President Joe Biden vacations in Southampton

The change our dollars will be worth we Obummer and his Wall Street cabinet get done devaluing our currency. How this is positive IDK. " Aug 3, 10 10:00 PM

East Quogue woman files $70 million lawsuit against Suffolk County and Southampton Town

Since when is County Road 31 an off limits area? She must have a pretty small trunk if a shotgun, AR15 and 140-500 rounds of ammo fill it up. She had 17 firearms under the legal limit in her trunk, that is right you can legally be in possession of 19 firearms outside of your home. Please don't hold your breath for the case to be thrown out, we would hate to lose you! lol
" Aug 4, 10 8:30 PM

If what you say is true does that change her protection under the constitution?" Aug 4, 10 8:31 PM

You are so predictable, when all logic, fact and are against you, out comes the racist crutch. It has no validity how do you know I'm not an El Salvadorian Muslim?" Aug 4, 10 8:34 PM

A graceful exit elliot. " Aug 4, 10 8:35 PM

Assembly race opponents exchange accusations

Fred you are arrogant and need to go. We have enough ineffectual politicians." Aug 4, 10 8:43 PM

McGintee to sue Town of East Hampton

What a set he has!" Aug 4, 10 8:44 PM

I think he meant townie in that you are from East Hampton and feel he has no reason to weigh in on this matter. I know living in Springs it is hard not to feel that others are looking down upon you, but I don't think that was the context townie was used in." Aug 4, 10 10:21 PM

Toxic algae bloom might be worse this year

This red tide originates in the Peconic River and enters Shinnecock Bay through the Shinnecock Canal. I bet it has to do with water temperature and the release of raw sewage from the over Riverhead's overburdened sewage treatment plant. " Aug 4, 10 10:29 PM

The out flow pipes for the Riverhead STP are quite a bit east of the the traffic circle, so I wouldn't expect to see the Red Tide upstream/river from them. Note I did say this Red Tide, so where it has been spotted in the past is irrelevant.
I'll tell you what though, we can be sure it has never gone from Shinnecock to Peconic, because the water only flows one way.... into Shinnecock.

Do you dispute that the Riverhead STP releases raw sewage into the Peconic River when it receives more wastewater than it can treat?

" Aug 6, 10 4:35 AM

East Quogue woman files $70 million lawsuit against Suffolk County and Southampton Town

True, I'm not! It however doesn't mean that I am a racist gun nut as this all to predicable poster has claimed. Any time someone doesn't agree with him they are either crazy, racist or a Neo Con. All this does is drawn attention to his lack of facts or law to support his opinions. The guns were legal and not an issue, so we are labeled "gun nuts"." Aug 6, 10 4:42 AM

Protest over Beach Hampton beach guards

That won't work as no vehicles are allowed on the beach during they day, even if parked." Aug 6, 10 7:07 AM

True accept where it is privately owned. In this case it is the access boardwalks that are privately owned, the issue is the mode of access, not the right to be on the beach." Aug 6, 10 7:10 AM


" Aug 6, 10 7:10 AM

Finally a voice of reason!" Aug 6, 10 7:15 AM

<<  1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |  5  |  6  |  7  |  8  |  9  |  10  |  11  |  12  |  >>